Pizza night is always a crowd-pleaser, but when you've got picky eaters in the house, it can be a bit of a balancing act to keep everyone happy. The good news? You don’t need to be a gourmet chef to make a pizza that even the fussiest eaters will love.
With a little creativity and some kid-approved toppings, you can turn dinner into a fun, stress-free family activity. Here are three simple and delicious pizza topping ideas that are sure to win over even the pickiest of eaters.
Sometimes, the simplest option is the best. A classic cheese pizza can be elevated to a new level by adding a playful twist, perfect for kids who shy away from veggies or unfamiliar flavors. Start with a base of marinara sauce spread thinly over the pizza crust, followed by a generous layer of mozzarella cheese. For an extra boost, consider blending a few different types of cheese, like mild cheddar or creamy Monterey Jack, for a flavor kids will devour.
Want to sneak in a little nutrition? Puree some cooked carrots or butternut squash into the marinara - it’s a sneaky way to add a dose of vitamins without anyone noticing. To make it extra fun, use cookie cutters to create shapes out of cheese slices and arrange them on top of the pizza before baking. Stars, hearts, or dinosaurs, kids will love helping you decorate the pizza with cheesy shapes!
Pepperoni is a go-to topping for a reason. It’s flavorful, familiar, and a total kid favorite. But why not switch it up and introduce some variety while keeping that familiar taste kids love? Try using turkey or chicken pepperoni for a leaner option, or provide a make-your-own pepperoni bar where kids can pick their favorite slices to top their section of the pizza.
For added fun, mini pepperoni slices or even pepperoni cut into unique shapes can bring a smile to your little one’s face. Arrange the slices in patterns like smiley faces or flowers to make the experience interactive. If your picky eaters avoid spice, make sure to pick a mild version of pepperoni that delivers all the flavor without overwhelming their sensitive palates.
Getting picky eaters to eat their vegetables can seem like an impossible mission - until you put it on a pizza! Hide healthy ingredients under layers of melted cheese so fussy eaters won’t even realize they’re eating their greens. A favorite trick is to finely chop veggies like spinach, bell peppers, or zucchini and mix them directly into the pizza sauce. Once everything is baked, they blend right in and are barely noticeable.
For older kids or those open to trying new things, consider roasting vegetables like broccoli, asparagus, or cherry tomatoes and letting them help arrange the toppings. Kids are more likely to eat veggies if they choose and place them themselves! You can even designate parts of the pizza for specific toppings for a personalized experience.
Dinner becomes less of a chore when it’s turned into an activity. For picky eaters, helping in the kitchen can make them more excited to try the food they’ve prepared. Set up a pizza station in your kitchen where kids can roll out dough, spread sauce, and sprinkle their toppings. This element of choice and creativity lets them feel in control and encouraged to try something new.
Think about creating a mini pizza night where everyone gets to customize their personal pie. Use small pre-made pizza crusts or even English muffins, pita bread, or naan for kid-sized creations. Handing over the reins might just mean they sprinkle a little cheese and call it a day, but hey, they’ll eat it happily, and that’s a parenting win!
Go Mild on Sauces: If marinara feels too tangy for your picky eater, try using ranch dressing, barbecue sauce, or even plain olive oil as an alternative base.
Keep It Small: Bite-sized pizzas or pizza dippers might encourage kids to try more flavors. Anything handheld is a win with little ones!
Encourage Exploration: Introduce toppings gradually. Add one new topping at a time, pairing it with things they already love. For example, sprinkle a few pieces of pineapple on top of their ham and cheese pizza or introduce a mild veggie near their usual favorites.
Serve With Familiar Sides: Pair your pizza with items kids already love, like raw veggies with dip or apple slices, to make the meal feel safe and approachable.
Try these ideas next time you’re planning dinner, and you might just turn your picky eater into a pizza fan for life. Whether it’s the joy of prepping their own pie or simply watching cheesy slices disappear in record time, pizza night will become a family tradition everyone looks forward to!
We have talked about the different types of pizza and how to make a delicious homemade pizza. But what about those times when you just don't feel like cooking? That's where Joe's Pizza Stone comes in. Located in Grand Prairie, we specialize in stone baked pizzas that are sure to satisfy your cravings.
Our pizzas are made with fresh, quality ingredients and cooked on a traditional stone oven for that perfect crispy crust. Drop by today!
